REFNATION
EconomyEnds 13 Sept 1h 0m left

Should the UK Government favour reducing public spending rather than raising taxes?

The UK national debt stands at nearly £3tn, with public spending above pre-pandemic levels and the tax burden forecast to reach historic highs. Prime Minister Andy Burnham and Chancellor John Healey face pressure ahead of the October 2026 Budget to meet fiscal rules without raising income tax, National Insurance or VAT, amid commitments on defence, social care and debt interest costs exceeding £100bn annually.

Jump to opinions· 30
Cast your vote814 votes so far

Vote to unlock the result — plus the full breakdown by age, gender, constituency and political leaning.

DocketAlso on today's ballot
Debate

30 Opinions

Sign in and vote to share your opinion.
Bigden40· 322
The Unifier
Voted yesRight lean

Absolutely 100% We need to stop talking about “investment” as a synonym of spending, it isn’t; stop treating increasing spending as some sort of achievement; and focus more on the outcomes achieved by the spending. Spending needs to come down, substantially, and front line services need not be impacted.

The Emerging Rightward Lean
Voted yesRight lean

The word 'services' needs defining. If spending for 'services' included inflated salaries and bonuses for MPs. Definitely. If benefits on non British citizens is 'services'. Definitely. If 'services' is PIP for able bodies people who are 'anxious'. Definitely.

JohnnyBoy· 295
The Motorist Statist
Voted yesRight lean

There is a psychotic obsession in UK assuming everything can be solved by raising existing taxes & finding additional ways of fleecing us. Looking at those who lean left, there is never even a hint of self awareness that Public Sector is broken, bloated, corrupt, inefficient,over remunerated, lazy & wastes £Billions & cannot ever get Department accounts signed off because of waste & corruption. Why are the Permanent Secretaries not sacked & prosecuted - Directors would be.

Seneca· 134
The Centurion
Voted yesRight lean

Our problem is a bloated state that does too much and spends too much. Taxes are already sky high, and probably can’t be raised any higher in a revenue positive way - many taxes are higher than their revenue maximising point on the laffer curve. Many opportunities exist to cut spending: - reuse the civil service to its pre Covid size - abolish foreign aid - abolish various quangos - cut welfare spending

Church15· 173
The Armed Workhorse
Voted yesC. Right lean

The government is running out of people to tax and is spending more than it is earning, making the bond markets worried about our inability to pay back our debts.

The Diplomat
Voted noH. Left lean

Public services are already in a truly dire state - anyone can look around their local area to see potholes, reduced bin collections, extortionate train fares, horrendous hospital waiting lists etc. etc. There just simply is no more to cut from public spending.

The Constituent
Voted noC. Left lean

Cost of living is hard but then things in life dont come free, if we want services to be a better quality then taxes must be raised but I think its more than fair to ask less of people who work and struggling and people on benefits and ask more of the richest 1% who aren't ever likely to struggle. So if done fairly and reasonably raise taxes and increase spending where essential.

The Early-Days Security Voter
Voted yesRight lean

When you are borrowing money to pay teh interest you owe on existing debt you are spending too much!

The Lean-State Disciplinarian
Voted yesRight lean

Britain is already at the Laffer Curve tipping point, and we cannot continue to have a european style welfare state with an american style tax system. The govt needs to cut taxes to stimulate the economy and to create more jobs If not, the increased taxes will have to be on everyone, because trying to load the costs on an increasingly small 'rich' sector will deliver negative returns

The Order-and-Restraint Moderate
Voted yesC. Right lean

You can’t keep taxing those who have so little.