Members back scrapping jury trial limits but reject longer election cycles

The day's most striking tension came on Is the EU Chat Control 2.0 legislation a threat to free speech in the UK? Members chose to view it as one, narrowly carrying the result in a debate that turned on whether a child-protection tool would inevitably expand into surveillance of dissent.

The verdicts

Was the government right to scrap plans to limit jury trials? delivered an overwhelming Yes; jury trial's defenders carried the argument even among some who opposed the government's retreat. Should the UK scrap the plastic bag charge? saw No win overwhelmingly, with defenders calling the levy a positive intervention to change behaviours and reduce waste while critics focused on who profits from bags still being sold.

Would longer election cycles allow UK governments to focus more on long-term decisions? produced the heaviest rejection of the day as No won overwhelmingly; the most-respected case against was simply "kicking the can down the road", with the argument centring less on planning benefits than on whether governments could be trusted with extra time. Should immigrants be required to adapt to British culture and practices, rather than expect change? saw Yes win overwhelmingly, the bluntest case captured by "obviously or why else come here" yet accompanied by a more qualified view that integration need not mean erasure.

Should personal drug use be decriminalised and handled by the NHS instead of police and courts? carried comfortably; the strongest case for change was not a defence of drug use but a plea to stop sending people whose addiction drives offending to prison rather than rehabilitation. Should the NHS reopen cottage hospitals to provide more local inpatient care? produced another overwhelming Yes, though the sharpest No arguments warned that reopening beds without nurses would spread scarcity rather than solve it.

Should the UK create the proposed National Police Service (NPS) as a British equivalent of the FBI? saw Yes win comfortably, despite pointed objections that the UK already has an agency created for much the same job; the sharpest exchange was over whether this is fresh capability or another rebrand.

Voting continues today on refnation.

Have your say

Every verdict above was decided by people like you. See the full results →

Today's referendums are already live. Cast your vote — or create an account and be counted.