Members lean on the Commonwealth and curb ticket pricing, but won't borrow for defence

The day's clearest message from refnation members was one of loyalty to the old arrangements: asked whether the UK should leave the Commonwealth to chase faster-growing parts of the world, members said no, overwhelmingly. The sharpest No voices called it a false choice, arguing the UK can stay, refuse reparations and still trade with the fast-growing world. Even the day's boldest ideas came with conditions attached.

The verdicts

On money and fairness, members were in a firm mood. They voted overwhelmingly to ban dynamic pricing for concerts and sport, with the most-respected Yes case a single blunt line calling it legalised profiteering with a fancy name. They also backed, overwhelmingly, the government's decision to shift council funding towards poorer areas, even though the sharpest argument came from No, which called council funding a return of people's hard-earned money. Yes voters answered more quietly, with need and neglect.

Defence produced two refusals. Members rejected, overwhelmingly, the idea that the Chancellor should borrow more to reach 3% of GDP on defence by 2030, yet almost nobody argued against the spending itself: the case was to cut welfare and foreign aid first, and the most-respected No went after contractors. On whether the RAF, as part of a European force, should defend Ukrainian skies, members voted no, comfortably, worried about escalation and cost. The most-respected Yes case was a jab about double standards, asking why jets can go to defend Saudi Arabia but not Ukraine.

Governance drew a tidy consensus. Members rejected, overwhelmingly, letting taxpayer-funded special advisers work on party business, and even a top-rated Yes voter agreed that all parties should pay their own advisers. The dispute was whether a constitutional pact counts as party business at all.

Two results ran through immigration and the classroom. Members voted comfortably to ban teachers in UK schools from wearing pro-Palestinian badges, and the winning case was broad: many wanted every political symbol covered, arguing teachers should teach the curriculum and keep their causes out of lessons. And on whether freedom of movement with the EU should stay ruled out, members voted against keeping it ruled out, comfortably, with No voters citing a plumber shortage and a wish to go there as easy.

A fresh ballot is open today, and the profiles keep building with every vote.

Have your say

Every verdict above was decided by people like you. See the full results →

Today's referendums are already live. Cast your vote — or create an account and be counted.