Members narrowly reject ban on March for Gaza

The narrowest verdict of the day came on the Should the Met police ban the March for Gaza planned for 7 October 2026? referendum. Members chose against banning the march, with the most-respected No voter arguing it was far better that the world sees people marking the anniversary of an attempted genocide. The debate turned on whether an offensive date alone justified a ban.

The verdicts

Members backed requiring all commercial dog breeders to hold a licence. For supporters, animal welfare made the case for extending rules already applied to many breeders; the proposal won overwhelmingly, though the sharpest dissent warned that compliance could squeeze out smaller businesses.

On Should the government give free childcare to families earning over £100,000? members voted against the idea. No won comfortably, but the argument voters most respected on the losing side was about fixing the cliff edge rather than making every high earner’s childcare free.

Members also rejected Should Britain adopt Swiss-style direct democracy with citizen-initiated referendums? No narrowly carried the vote by warning that a petition system could turn complex choices into a stream of badly framed national tests, despite Yes voters’ desire to wrest decisions from representatives they said had failed them.

Should parents no longer be fined for taking children on holiday during term time? saw members vote yes. For families priced out of school-holiday travel the choice was put starkly: go during term time, or don’t go at all. Yes won comfortably, while the best-respected No argument objected not to the policy but to the question’s wording.

Members decisively voted against classifying Zionism as racism. No won overwhelmingly, but the debate was less tidy than the verdict: the best-respected Yes case called Zionism “ethnic supremacy”, while No voters argued both for Jewish self-determination and for keeping criticism of Israel open.

On boosting youth organisations, members chose for funding 30% growth in cadets, Scouts and Guides by 2035. A childhood memory of Scouts carried the Yes case; Yes won comfortably, though the debate was less about whether youth groups matter than which ones government should back.

Finally, members rejected Should the UK government support a US military seizure of Iran’s Kharg Island? No won comfortably, with voters’ sharpest divide over whether the island was leverage or a trap; the best-respected arguments against warned that seizing it could mean an open-ended war.

Voting continues today on refnation.

Have your say

Every verdict above was decided by people like you. See the full results →

Today's referendums are already live. Cast your vote — or create an account and be counted.