Members overwhelmingly reject London independence

Refnation members delivered a wall of resistance to the idea of Greater London breaking away as an independent city-state. The proposal met almost universal rejection, even as its strongest argument cleverly turned the rest of the UK's gripes about the capital into a case for letting it go its own way.

The verdicts

Should local councillors receive intensive training at the start of their tenure after being elected? Members treated the role as a demanding public job rather than something candidates must master before standing; Yes won overwhelmingly.

Should tech companies be held responsible for crimes committed on their platforms? The floor split almost down the middle on whether platforms are like landlords knowingly hosting fraud or mere tools in a criminal's hands. Yes prevailed, though the most-respected argument came from the No side.

Should the UK create an NHS-style social care system, free at the point of use? Despite sharp warnings about affordability and more No voices in the debate, members backed a system that would make care free at the point of use.

Should the government release hate crime figures broken down by nationality? Transparency carried the room, with members favouring audited and carefully qualified data over fears that the figures would simply become political ammunition.

Should the UK reclaim exclusive control of fishing in its 12-mile coastal zone? Members voted decisively to take back control, though the sharpest exchanges centred on the likely costs in tariffs and lost trust; the most-respected Yes voice branded the current deal a betrayal.

Should the UK Government offer equity loans to first-time buyers with deposits as low as 2.5%? In the day's closest result, the scheme scraped through despite the floor's most-respected argument favouring more housebuilding to bring prices down. The winning case appealed to helping buyers without family wealth.

If IRGC involvement in the RAF Fairford bomb plot is proven, should the UK take military action in response? Members chose restraint over retaliation. The divide turned less on whether a proven plot deserved consequences than on whether military action was the right form.

Voting continues today on a fresh ballot.

Have your say

Every verdict above was decided by people like you. See the full results →

Today's questions are already live. Cast your vote — or create an account and be counted.