UK Backs Lifeboats Over Migrant Ban

The single most striking result of the day was the clear rejection of any ban on the RNLI launching to rescue people in migrant small boats, even when tasked by the Coastguard. Two in three voters chose the lifeboat’s duty over the migrant question, though many who voted No still objected to the charity becoming what they called a “taxi service”. The verdict was a firm No, but not a blank cheque for current arrangements.

The verdicts

Should we legalise cannabis for recreational use? edged through with a narrow Yes as the room concluded that the war on drugs had failed to stop usage; regulation was pitched against warnings of normalisation and mental-health risks.

Should the national inquiry into grooming gangs be widened? saw the country vote overwhelmingly Yes. A survivor warned that more inquiries were not needed, yet the chamber demanded a broader investigation alongside the prosecutions and protection that inquiries alone cannot deliver.

On rights, the UK agreed that the country applies face-covering rules inconsistently by exempting burkas, niqabs and hijabs. Religious exemption was seen as the loophole, with the strongest line insisting rules must apply to all regardless of reasons.

Should judges face formal disciplinary action for repeated disregard of statute or binding precedent? passed with huge support. “We have laws for a reason” carried the day, though opponents warned that judicial independence would be the price.

The country also backed a right to say no to conscription without punishment, with nearly two in three voting Yes. “We are free people not livestock” captured the instinct, yet many supporters still accepted some alternative duty to serve.

On the economy the room said No to England’s mayors having powers to charge uncapped levies on business overnight stays, rejecting the idea nearly three to one. Even some Yes voters called for limits, agreeing that business travel is not a luxury holiday.

Finally, voters dismissed the claim that most current job vacancies in the private sector offer no measurable social or economic value. Ordinary work from care to cleaning was defended; the premise itself was treated as the provocation.

Voting continues today.

Have your say

Every verdict above was decided by people like you. See the full results →

Today's questions are already live. Cast your vote — or create an account and be counted.