Gunboats and Drilling Win Big as Lords Reform Splits Country

The country sent a blunt message on immigration and energy yesterday, voting to put navy gun boats in the channel and open the North Sea for fresh drilling, even as the sharpest arguments on both questions came from the losing side.

The verdicts

Should we put navy gun boats in the channel? delivered a clear 14-point win for Yes, yet the chamber's most respected contributions almost all opposed the idea. A similar mismatch appeared on Should the House of Lords be replaced with a Per Population representation along County borders with Professional Reps?, where two in three backed radical reform but the best line warned it would simply fill the chamber with more special advisers.

On Should taxpayers fund gender affirming surgery and medication? the country delivered a three-to-one rout for No, and this time the winning side also won the argument: the single most respected contribution dismissed the entire premise outright. Should the government introduce a wealth tax to fund adult social care reform in England? proved far tighter, the UK split almost down the middle, yet almost every voice on the page came from the No benches; the case for a wealth tax was barely heard.

Should the UK open up the North Sea for oil drilling? saw a near three-to-one landslide for Yes on the unchallenged logic that importing energy while sitting on domestic reserves is self-defeating for both the Treasury and, in the winners' view, emissions. Are social media 'influencers' given too much credibility by the mainstream media? produced the day's heaviest margin, four in five saying yes, with not one dissenting argument troubling the page.

Should households near new electricity transmission infrastructure receive up to £250 annual bill discounts for 10 years? passed narrowly, the country endorsing compensation for communities that host pylons and substations even if enthusiasm looked lukewarm. Finally the chamber voted down its own premise on Do online political polling forums significantly influence election outcomes or policy?, three in five saying no, despite most of the substantive debate coming from the Yes side.

Voting continues today on fresh questions.

Have your say

Every verdict above was decided by people like you. See the full results →

Today's questions are already live. Cast your vote — or create an account and be counted.