UK votes to ramp up defence and calls economy broken

The UK woke up to a sobering verdict on its own condition. By nearly four voices to one the country declared that the economy is in serious trouble, with voters pointing to a mountain of debt and offering no serious counter-argument. Almost as emphatically, two in three backed a major increase in defence spending, echoing the old line that if you want peace you must prepare for war.

The verdicts

Is the UK economy in serious trouble? saw the chamber give a near-unanimous Yes, capturing a mood of blunt realism. Should the United Kingdom increase spending on defence of the realm? followed with an equally decisive Yes, every posted argument landing on the winning side.

On more divisive territory the country split almost down the middle. Is Rupert Lowe right that mass migration is the core driver of grooming gang scandals? produced a narrow Yes, the strongest voices framing the issue as one of communal impunity that leaves Britain fractured rather than settled. Is diversity our strength? delivered a clearer No, one voter’s blunt “Never was” carrying the day while the Yes side offered the more qualified, evidence-led case.

Defence questions continued to draw strong support for action. Should the UK independently seize frozen Russian state assets to fund support for Ukraine? passed with a clear but not overwhelming Yes, though the most respected argument in the chamber counselled restraint. On the home front Should the Government embark on a massive programme of building council homes similar to post-Second World War? also secured a Yes, yet the best-rated contributions pushed for a Singapore-style model of public housing sold at cost rather than a straight return to the old approach.

Constitutional and transport questions produced narrower rejections. Should England or its regions have a devolved Parliament in the same way as Northern Ireland, Scotland and Wales? was turned down, the winning side arguing for a return to a Parliament never designed to break up the Union. Should HS2 be completed despite the higher costs and longer timescale? fell by the slimmest of margins, voters reluctantly concluding that the money is already sunk and the damage already done.

Voting continues today on fresh questions facing the country.

Have your say

Every verdict above was decided by people like you. See the full results →

Today's questions are already live. Cast your vote — or create an account and be counted.