UK votes to keep the monarchy and tighten welfare rules

The UK delivered a firm vote to keep the monarchy, rejecting an elected head of state by two to one. The sharpest exchanges were not about the King himself but whether a president would genuinely improve democracy or simply open the door to “President Mandelson”.

The verdicts

Should the UK replace the monarchy with an elected head of state? No carried the day comfortably.

Is Robert Jenrick right that long-term welfare harms young people rather than supporting them? The country agreed nearly three to one, treating long-term dependency as the central harm even though the losing side landed the floor’s sharpest line: “Blaming the safety net confuses the symptom with the disease.”

Should foreign nationals, including EU citizens, be barred from most UK benefits? Yes won clearly, though the most memorable arguments came from the No side and one voter described the current system as a “calamitous mistake” that cannot easily be undone.

Do most voters understand the manifesto of the party they vote for? The country said no by an overwhelming margin, dismissing manifestos as soundbites rather than contracts and blaming unread detail.

Should in-work benefits be replaced with a higher minimum wage? A narrow Yes verdict prevailed after the best-rated line of the debate — “Taxpayers shouldn’t subsidise profitable businesses paying poverty wages” — carried the room, despite No supplying most of the running commentary.

Can the UK still recruit, retain and defend itself militarily if national unity has weakened? The chamber gave No a clear two-to-one verdict, apparently unmoved by the losing side’s claim that “soldiers fight for their fellow soldiers.”

Does the Israel lobby have too much influence over western policy? Yes edged it, though voters seemed to respect the sharpest No arguments most; one remarked that “too many lobbies have too much influence.”

Should mobile networks be required to provide full 5G coverage to all UK homes within 100 miles of main cities? Universal 5G won a clear mandate, even as the floor’s best-rated contributions insisted coverage should follow demand rather than coercion.

Voting continues today on fresh questions.

Have your say

Every verdict above was decided by people like you. See the full results →

Today's questions are already live. Cast your vote — or create an account and be counted.