UK votes to keep Notting Hill Carnival and BBFC powers

The UK came within a whisker of banning Notting Hill Carnival after a weekend of record arrests, yet ultimately decided the event should stay. The narrowest call of the day split the country almost down the middle, with the ban camp landing the sharpest line: if an event needs an army and a pre-ban list, it has already failed.

The verdicts

Should Notting Hill Carnival be banned produced the closest result, but the room chose to let it continue. In Should the UK deepen trade ties and offer Canada tariff relief, two in three backed closer links with Ottawa, favouring solidarity over sitting out the US trade war. The country also said Yes to keeping the BBFC’s powers in In a free society should the BBFC still have so much power, a narrow verdict framed less as enthusiasm for censorship than a plea for guardrails.

Voters were in no mood for half-measures on quangos. Should Quangos be scrapped delivered a thumping Yes, less a detailed policy argument than a demand that someone, somewhere, finally own the decisions. The same impatience showed in Are we heading for techno-feudalism, where the room answered with a blunt “headed? we are,” citing rents, data and digital gatekeepers.

On transport, Will full self-drive cars replace all taxis saw the country say No by two to one, with British roads dismissed as too cluttered and complicated for the “eventually” promised by enthusiasts. Digital rights proved the clearest consensus of the day: Do consumer digital rights need to be improved produced an overwhelming Yes, turning deliberate loss of access into a question of refunds and remedy. Finally, Should the Bank of England allow the pound to depreciate saw the currency defended by more than two to one, every posted argument coming from the No side.

Voting continues today on fresh questions.

Have your say

Every verdict above was decided by people like you. See the full results →

Today's questions are already live. Cast your vote — or create an account and be counted.