refnation
Should all drivers have to retake a driving assessment every few years?
TransportEnds 12 Oct 18h 57m left

Should all drivers have to retake a driving assessment every few years?

UK driving licences are valid until age 70 with renewal every 10 years and no mandatory retesting for any drivers. From age 70, renewal is required every 3 years via self-declaration of health and eyesight standards, with no practical driving test required. The government has consulted on mandatory eyesight tests for over-70s but has confirmed no plans for driving retests for any age group.

Jump to opinions· 9
Cast your vote102 votes so far

Vote to unlock the result — plus the full breakdown by age, gender, constituency and political leaning.

DocketAlso on today's ballot
Debate

9 Opinions

Sign in and vote to share your opinion.
The Sovereignty Custodian
Voted yesH. Right lean

The roads of today have different traffic and rules than they did 20 or 40 years ago. For example, the Hierarchy of Road Users (H1-H3). Retesting would help ensure that current drivers are sufficiently safe for the roads as they are now, not as they were years ago.

The Firm Conservative
Voted noH. Right lean

Not unless there's a reason to do so. Such as a change in health.

The Dissenter
Voted noLeft lean

There are quite a lot of drivers about, are there enough driving examiners to go round? The wait for a test would be far too long, with the possibility of it being a year or more. There are driving simulators to practice on. Could the over 70's take a test on those instead of having the stress of a real road test?

BenL· 449
THE NANNY-STATE ALLERGIC
Voted noC. Left lean

Learners already wait half a year just to book a driving test. Where are we magically finding an army of examiners to retest 35 million drivers every few years? The DVSA would collapse overnight. I think we need mandatory eyesight tests for the over 70s and retests should there be X amount of at-fault incidents in a 5 year time scale but blanket retests just punish even the safest of drivers with a blemish free record for 20+ years etc.

Spargrass· 405
The Modest Fiscal Hawk
Voted noC. Right lean

There should be a mandatory health check, covering eyesight, physical ability and reaction times etc

The Civic Libertarian
Voted noC. Right lean

Expensive, impractical and ultimately pointless it wouldn't catch anything or improve standards

Slawomir· 909
The Accountable Capitalist
Voted noRight lean

No, not possible to execute. Some could for example if exceeding average of participation in collisions. Or receiving too many fines.

JohnKelly· 240
The Taxpayer’s Commandant
Voted noRight lean

Maybe make the test harder or add a second harder test after the first, to raise the initial quality. But mandatory regular retests would be costly and aren’t really needed.

The Polymath
Voted noC. Left lean

Not everyone should have to retake, just those over 70 or recently diagnosed with conditions that impair driving.