REFNATION
JusticeNationalClosed · Final

Should the UK change the 1971 law to allow deportation of Shabir Ahmed?

Yes 84%No 16%86 votes cast

Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood will outline legal steps to deport Shabir Ahmed, the ringleader of the Rochdale grooming gang. Ahmed was jailed for 22 years in 2012 for child sexual offences, stripped of British citizenship, and released on licence this month. A 1971 law currently prevents his removal as a Commonwealth citizen who arrived over 50 years ago, and Pakistan may not accept him.

SourceBBC News
Jump to opinions

There are votes that split a country and votes that simply confirm what almost everyone already believed, and this was emphatically the second kind: five in six of the 86 who took part backed changing the 1971 rule to clear the way for Shabir Ahmed's deportation. What's striking isn't the winning margin so much as its total absence of a fault line — the 55-64s, the group most engaged here, backed it as strongly as the youngest voters did, and women were, if anything, marginally more united than men.

That flatness is itself the story. Grooming-gang cases have become one of the few issues where public anger cuts cleanly across the usual splits of age and politics, and this vote reproduces that pattern in miniature — nobody organised into a "no" bloc worth the name, just a scattering of dissenters in every bracket.

The result lands on a genuinely live fault line: Britain's post-imperial citizenship law, built for a different era of Commonwealth ties, running up against a public that increasingly wants deportation powers to follow the crime rather than the paperwork. Shabana Mahmood's proposed fix, on this evidence, isn't a hard sell.

The debate here wasn't whether to close the loophole, but why it was ever open.

LeftCentreRight
  • E
    Enginesan· 487
    The Anti-Corporate InstitutionalistLeft
    YES
  • K
    The BellwetherCentre Right
    YES
  • The Public Ownership DissenterLeft
    NO
  • Rabbit· 245
    The Rights-First Housing DissenterLeft
    YES
  • J
    JulesB· 36
    The Market-First LoyalistHard Right
    YES
  • The Consensus LeftistLeft
    YES
  • The Hawk Who Doubts the WarRight
    YES
  • hr97· 389
    THE FORTRESS REDISTRIBUTORCentre Left
    YES
  • The KingmakerHard Left
    NO
  • Migano· 48
    The Left-Leaning PragmatistLeft
    YES
  • M
    mpwban· 186
    The Rearmed StatistLeft
    NO
  • R
    The Sovereignty DissenterHard Right
    YES
  • robvrn· 225
    The Accountable-State FirebrandLeft
    YES
  • The Green Rights DissenterLeft
    YES
  • The Unbending NewcomerRight
    YES
  • A
    The Green Constitutional RealistCentre Left
    NO
  • T
    The Green Order-KeeperCentre
    YES
  • SarahJ· 42
    The Loyal LeftLeft
    YES
  • The Deportation HardlinerHard Right
    YES
  • The Skeptical LeftistLeft
    NO
84%
Yes · 72 votes
16%
No · 14 votes
Yes No
By gender
Male
83/17
Female
93/7
By age
16–24
78/22
25–34
82/18
35–44
82/18
45–54
85/15
55–64
87/13
65+
82/18
By political leaning
H. Left
0/100
Left
63/37
C. Left
89/11
Centre
80/20
C. Right
90/10
Right
100/0
H. Right
100/0
Spread the wordShare
Debate

0 Opinions

Sign in and vote to share your opinion.

Weigh in on the debate.