Verdicts

The verdict

The chamber's rejection of higher National Insurance to buy back a lower retirement age, by three to one, cuts against the very generation you might expect to champion it: the 55-64s, closest to the state pension line themselves, voted down the trade-off almost two to one.

The verdict

A clear if not overwhelming majority backed extending the watershed beyond television, with the chamber's oldest voters most convinced that advertising restrictions belong alongside the 2025 rules while younger and middle-aged voters stayed genuinely split.

The verdict

Rare is the vote on this platform that unites 16-year-olds and pensioners alike, but a call for wholesale reform of prisons in England and Wales did just that, passing by six to one among the 124 who logged a view.

The verdict

A purge of the old regime split the chamber less than you'd expect from a Cabinet reshuffle this brutal, with three in five voters here backing Burnham's right to clear house even as the deposed faction's sympathisers cried foul.

The verdict

There is a striking uniformity to this one: whatever the age bracket, roughly seven in ten voters backed compelling government buybacks of unsellable shared ownership homes, a rare instance of consensus cutting clean across the generational lines that usually split housing votes.

The verdict

A clear two-to-one majority backed tightening PIP eligibility, with the sharpest resistance coming not from the young claimants often blamed for rising anxiety-related awards but from the youngest voters themselves, who split against reform.

The verdict

On a question that dressed up welfare conditionality in a clinical wrapper, the chamber declined the offer decisively, with roughly two in three voters saying no to state-funded jabs for the unemployed rather than accept the York study's productivity logic at face value.

The verdict

Scrapping digital ID found almost nobody willing to defend it on this floor, with every age band and every woman who voted lining up behind Burnham's decision to shelve the scheme in favour of the electricity VAT cut.

The verdict

A clear majority here wants platforms in the legal firing line for misinformation, with the chamber backing liability by roughly three to two — though the shape of that support, strongest among the very young and the over-65s, suggests less consensus than the topline implies.

The verdict

The chamber declined to hand Holyrood the legal shield Westminster enjoys, with No winning by twelve points, in a vote that split cleanly along generational lines over how much trust to extend to politicians debating sensitive evidence.

The verdict

A chamber that skews young and asset-poor looked at Britain's tax code and concluded, two to one, that it tilts toward wealth over wages — a verdict that says less about the arithmetic of capital gains rates than about who feels squeezed by it.

The verdict

On a question meant to test faith in Britain's ability to go it alone, the chamber delivered something closer to a verdict on decline than a vote of confidence, with barely one in six willing to say the armed forces could defend the country without NATO behind them.

The verdict

A vote this evenly cleft could hardly have delivered a cleaner non-verdict: on Burnham's pitch for deeper devolution without a fresh constitutional fight, the chamber split down to the last ballot, No prevailing by a single vote of 121 cast.

The verdict

A narrow national majority for legalising assisted dying masks a chamber that never settled into a clean generational or ideological line, with the 45-54s the most resistant age group even as those a decade older swung firmly the other way.

The verdict

The chamber that grew up with smartphones was the one most sceptical of putting a ballot on one: even the 16-24s, digital natives to a person, voted down online voting almost unanimously, and the wider verdict followed suit as No prevailed by two to one.

The verdict

A verdict this lopsided in a chamber this small still carries a signal: scrapping digital ID and unleashing more North Sea drilling found the floor almost of one mind, with 11 of the 13 who voted backing Burnham's opening gambit, even as the handful of women present pulled the other way.

The verdict

With just eleven votes cast and barely a whisker separating the sides, this was less a verdict than a shrug: a chamber this narrowly split, and this small, suggests Britain's light-touch AI approach commands no settled consensus even among those minded to weigh in.

The verdict

A single vote separated the two camps, which is the real finding here — a chamber almost perfectly split on whether the state should once again become Britain's biggest housebuilder, with No edging it by the narrowest of margins.

The verdict

A chamber asked to weigh consensus against conflict came down hard for conflict, with almost two in three voters here concluding that politics without losers is politics without decisions — though the middle-aged did most of the deciding, not the young.

The verdict

On a question of who pays for the energy transition, the chamber's answer was emphatic: shift the cost off bills and onto the taxpayer, with four in five voters backing a £130 giveaway that quietly makes heat pumps cheaper to run than gas boilers.

The verdict

After a former MP's killing put political violence at the top of the news, the chamber reached for the blunt instrument of the law almost unanimously, backing arrest for anyone who threatens to shoot an MP by well over four to one.

The verdict

A brief, unloved premiership got a brief, unloved verdict: two in five voters here credited Keir Starmer with leaving Britain better than he found it, but a clear majority marked his short tenure down as a net loss.

The verdict

Two-thirds backing for a state-brokered pay deal for care workers masks a striking gender split: men embraced the Fair Pay Agreement by roughly seven in ten, while women — who make up the overwhelming majority of the care workforce itself — tilted against it, the chamber's 78-38 verdict built almost entirely on male enthusiasm.

The verdict

A narrow win for Labour's grey belt strategy, with the chamber splitting almost along gender lines as much as any planning logic, as voters backed releasing lower-quality green belt for housing by a slim margin.